Finance

Tesla's data confirms Model S that crashed into fire truck had Autopilot engaged

Tesla crash
The driver kept her hands off the wheel for 80 seconds before the collision, according to a report Tesla created after examining the vehicle's data logs and provided to the South Jordan Police Department. South Jordan Police Department via AP
Read in app
  • Tesla has confirmed that the Model S which crashed into a fire department vehicle in Utah on Friday had Autopilot engaged at the time of the collision, according to a report from the South Jordan Police Department.
  • The driver had her hands off the wheel and was looking at her phone before the crash, according to a report Tesla made after examining the vehicle's data logs and provided to the South Jordan Police Department.
  • Tesla has repeatedly said drivers must be attentive, keep their hands on the wheel, and be able to take control of the vehicle when using Autopilot, which is not a fully autonomous system.


Tesla has confirmed that the Model S which crashed into a fire department vehicle in Utah on Friday had Autopilot engaged at the time of the collision, according to a report from the South Jordan Police Department.

The South Jordan Police Department released the report, which provides new details about the events that led to the crash, on Wednesday. The new details come from a report Tesla created after examining the vehicle's data logs and provided to the South Jordan Police Department.

The driver took her hands off the wheel before the crash

According to Tesla's report, the driver turned Autopilot's semi-autonomous driver assistance features on and off multiple times during the drive. The report states that the driver took her hands off the wheel over 12 times during the drive. Twice, the driver had her hands off the wheel for over a minute, returning them to the wheel briefly after receiving a visual warning, the report says.

About 82 seconds before the crash, the driver re-engaged Autopilot and kept her hands off the wheel for 80 seconds before the collision, according to the report. The report also says that the vehicle was traveling at around 60 mph at the time of the collision, a speed the driver selected.

It was previously reported that the driver told police she had been looking at her phone at the time of the collision, which left her with a broken ankle.

Autopilot requires hands on the wheel

Tesla has repeatedly said drivers must be attentive, keep their hands on the wheel, and be able to take control of the vehicle when using Autopilot, which is not a fully autonomous system. The system can keep a car in its lane and adjust its speed based on surrounding traffic.

Tesla CEO Elon Musk wrote about the crash and the response it received on Twitter on Monday.

"It’s super messed up that a Tesla crash resulting in a broken ankle is front page news and the ~40,000 people who died in US auto accidents alone in past year get almost no coverage," he wrote.

"What’s actually amazing about this accident is that a Model S hit a fire truck at 60mph and the driver only broke an ankle. An impact at that speed usually results in severe injury or death," he wrote in another tweet.

"When using Autopilot, drivers are continuously reminded of their responsibility to keep their hands on the wheel and maintain control of the vehicle at all times," a Tesla representative told Business Insider in an email. "Tesla has always been clear that Autopilot doesn’t make the car impervious to all accidents."

Other crashes involving Autopilot have drawn attention

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has sent a team to investigate the crash. 

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) is investigating four crashes involving Tesla vehicles, some of which involve Autopilot. The agency is not investigating Friday's crash.

In March, a Model X crashed into a highway barrier in Mountain View, California, while Autopilot was engaged. The driver, Walter Huang, died after being taken to the hospital. Tesla said the driver had received multiple warnings to return his hands to the wheel throughout the drive and indicated a shortened impact attenuator increased the damage to Huang and the vehicle.

In January, a Model S crashed into a fire department vehicle in California while Autopilot was engaged.

While some competitors, like General Motors, Nissan, and Daimler, have also introduced driver assistance features with similar capabilities, others are nervous about including semi-autonomous systems in their vehicles because they fear drivers will place too much trust in them and fail to pay attention to the road.

Read next

I'm a senior transportation reporter at Insider covering electric vehicles, automated-driving technology, and ride-hailing. I joined Insider in October 2017 and previously worked as an intern at the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. I graduated from Washington University in St. Louis with degrees in film and media studies and business economics. You can follow me on Twitter @matousekmark and email me at mmatousek@jkmperu.com If you have sensitive information you'd like to share and don't feel comfortable sending it to my work email or via a direct-message on Twitter, you can contact me on the encrypted messaging app Signal at 646-768-4712 or email my encrypted address at mmatousek@protonmail.com. Here's some of my work: Uber insiders are divided over Dara Khosrowshahi's leadership, with some worried the company has become 'boring' and 'confused' about its future Nikola founder Trevor Milton convinced the world he was the next Elon Musk. Insiders say a history of lies brought the billionaire down. 17 hours a day, 7 days a week: Cruise-ship workers describe the grueling conditions they face on the job We talked to 42 insiders about Tesla's factory of the future. They revealed the corners cut to hit ambitious production targets. 70-hour weeks and 'WTF' emails: 42 employees reveal the frenzy of working at Tesla under the 'cult' of Elon Musk Tesla is transforming how cars are sold. But 27 insiders say the company's methods mean slashed pay and living under the constant threat of getting laid off. Uber insiders reveal how DoorDash stole its delivery crown and left Eats in the dust Uber's trying no-meeting Mondays to give employees a break from 'tiring' back-to-back meetings, a leaked email reveals Leaked email reveals a Tesla VP expressed concern about employees coming to work with COVID-19 symptoms Leaked document reveals Nikola flip-flopped on whether it would spend any of its $17 million of customer deposits to fund the Nikola One Insiders reveal Alibaba's Jack Ma sought a partnership with Canoo to build electric delivery vans, but the deal fell flat because the startup couldn't meet his aggressive timeline Leaked email from Elon Musk reveals the Model Y is experiencing production 'challenges' while passing the Model 3 as the top priority at Tesla's US car factory Leaked email and audio reveal Carnival-owned Holland America has struggled to give refunds to some customers Leaked documents reveal the severance packages laid off Carnival UK workers will receive Inside Tesla's overhaul plan for its sales and delivery teams to solve one of its toughest customer challenges