Retail

Instacart's profitability relies in part on batching orders together — something that its gig workers hate

A man wearing a face mask and sunglasses backwards on his head looks at a receipt while standing in front of a shopping cart at a Giant grocery store in Washington DC in 2020.
Instacart has gotten its shoppers to deliver more orders at a time for the same or less pay over the last few years. Evelyn Hockstein/For The Washington Post via Getty Images
Read in app

Instacart's IPO filing shows the company turned a profit last year. An increase in productivity by its gig workers contributed to that profit.

Since 2019, Instacart has increased its "batch rate," or the average number of orders shopped and delivered in a single trip, by 50%, according to the filing. Instead of having one shopper fill a single order at a time, Instacart has pushed its gig workers to shop and deliver multiple orders at once.

That's one of the factors that helped the company turn a profit last year. In 2021, Instacart booked a net loss of $73 million, according to the prospectus it filed with the SEC. In 2022, it reported a profit of $428 million. Other factors, such as its growing advertising business, also factored into the company's profitability.

"We drive efficiencies through the number of orders powered by technology-backed picking and batching abilities that help shoppers fulfill multiple orders simultaneously," a section of the prospectus titled "Economies of Scale" reads.

The practice of batching helps efficiency "by reducing the cost and time to fulfill each order," the section says.

Filling multiple orders at once has become a feature of shopping for Instacart — and one that shoppers say has weighed on their earnings.

Instacart frequently batches two or three orders together. Shoppers have to accept all of the orders in a batch to shop them and receive their pay, several Instacart workers have told Insider over the last few months.

But shoppers who have worked for Instacart for several years have told Insider that their pay per order has decreased since batching became widespread. One Instacart shopper in Utah told Insider earlier this year that three-order batches, which shoppers call "triples," have become commonplace.

In early 2020, by contrast, they were "pretty rare," and many paid better than regular orders. Now, the shopper said, she has to fill more orders than three years ago to make the same amount of money — or, in some cases, less.

Instacart shoppers are also coping with lower pay on other fronts. A month before filing its IPO papers, Instacart cut base pay for shoppers to $4 an order from $7.

Are you an Instacart shopper with a story to share? Reach out to this reporter at abitter@insider.com

Read next

Screen Shot 2020 09 04 at 6.22.07 PM
Alex Bitter
Alex Bitter is a senior retail reporter covering the gig economy, food, and retail. His work focuses major gig delivery and ride-hailing apps, including Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, Instacart, and Walmart's Spark. He is interested in everything from what it's like to work on the apps to the companies' business strategies.Some of his recent stories feature gig workers who have been deactivated on the apps, DoorDash hiring traditional employees to make deliveries, gig workers' use of bots, and gig work expanding into new professions, such as nursing.Alex has also written about Aldi's US expansionStarbucks' turnaround efforts, and the fallout from Kraft-Heinz's budget cutting. Convenience store chain Sheetz ended its "smile policy" after his reporting.Before joining Insider in September 2020, he wrote about consumer and retail companies for S&P Global Market Intelligence. He's a graduate of the University of Hawai'i at Mānoa and grew up on the Big Island.Alex lives in the Washington, DC, area, where you can find him studying ancient coins or searching for Civil War artifacts with his metal detector in his free time.Got a tip? Reach out at abitter@jkmperu.com or via encrypted messaging app Signal at +1 (808) 854-4501.