Politics

Warren and Sanders say canceling student debt could help close the racial wealth gap for families. This startling graph shows they might be right.

Morehouse College black college students
Members of the graduating class of 2013 attend their graduation ceremony at Morehouse College in Atlanta, Georgia, May 19, 2013. REUTERS/Jason Reed
Read in app

The US might need to look to the student-debt crisis to address racial inequality.

Americans are currently saddled with $1.5 trillion worth of student-loan debt, and the total amount of debt young people owe is the highest since immediately before the 2008 financial crisis.

Democratic presidential contenders Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren both released plans that would eliminate the debt entirely. Their campaigns have said canceling student debt would help black and brown families much more than white ones.

The crisis has hit minority communities worse than white families on average. Black graduates default on their loans (meaning they do not make a payment within 270 days) at five times the rate of white graduates, and graduates from historically black colleges have 32% more debt than other students.

Read more: People are fleeing the US to keep from paying off their student loans

While black household wealth has long been lower than that of white families, canceling student debt could narrow the divide. An analysis by the Roosevelt Institute, a liberal think tank based in New York, found that white households headed by people between the ages of 25 and 40 have 12 times the amount of wealth on average than black households.

Yet without student debt, the ratio shrinks to just five times the amount of wealth — although as this chart shows, it still remains quite wide:

student debt and racial wealth gap
Business Insider/Andy Kiersz, data from Marshall Steinbaum

"Canceling student debt for black households matters more for their net worth than for white households," Marshall Steinbaum, one of the study's authors, said in an interview with Business Insider.

Steinbaum used data from the Survey of Consumer Finances, which is conducted by the Federal Reserve. The study focused on the median wealth of households headed by black and white people aged 25 to 40. 

Currently, black college grads from four-year schools take on $7,400 more in loans than white students. Black workers take on higher debt in part due to discrimination in the workplace, Steinbaum said. Black college graduates are more likely to face discrimination, which includes "being treated unfairly in hiring, pay, or promotion," than those without degrees, according to the Pew Research Center.

Because of the larger amount of student debt taken on, even black college grads working high-paying jobs have an average net worth that's much lower than white families. Canceling student debt, therefore, could bring the median net worth between the two demographics much closer.

Read next

Allana Akhtar was a senior health reporter for Insider, where she covers the emerging wellness industry and general health topics. During the COVID-19 pandemic, Allana wrote extensively about nurses, mask mandates, the vaccine rollout, and disparities in access to health. Her articles include features on nurses needing to re-use PPE in the early days of the pandemic, ones who struggled to get paid time off after getting COVID-19, and those who left bedside care after grueling pandemic working conditions. Allana also spoke to flight attendants and retail workers who faced violence as they enforced mask mandates, and community health workers who said they struggled to receive equitable vaccine access during the initial rollout. Allana now reports on emerging trends within the wellness industry, including the Westernization of indigenous medicine and dangerous wellness trends spread through social media. She also writes about plastic surgery, racial disparities in healthcare, and breaking health news. Allana has won numerous awards for her work, including the Best News Story by the Michigan Press Association in 2015, Best Reporter Covering Nurses in 2019, and the Morris and Lola Wasserstein Award for her contribution to the the University of Michigan's student paper as an Honors student. Before Insider, Allana wrote for USA TODAY, US News & World Report, Money Magazine, Health Magazine, Jalopnik, and more. You can email her at aakhtar@jkmperu.com, call/text her at (646) 376-6058, or follow her on Instagram, TikTok, Twitter, and LinkedIn. Secure tips line: Signal # 248 760 0208'We're grossly unprepared': Nurses share their frustration as the coronavirus spreads with little direction from the government or hospitals on how to mitigate it'Sexy nurse' costumes demean one of the most in-demand professions in American life — and they're a bestseller on Amazon right nowFlight attendants describe 'unprecedented' violence as travel returns and passenger aggression soarsG/O Media fired a queer employee of color who wore crop tops, shorts, and heels to work, violating a brand-new dress code that others say they routinely violated without being punishedContractors at controversial startup Rev say they worked long hours for little pay, feared they could lose their job at any time, and had to transcribe interviews with sexual-abuse survivors without warning