Sports

Hard tackle to the chest could have triggered a rare heart condition in Damar Hamlin, doctors say

Damar Hamlin #3 of the Buffalo Bills reacts to a play against the Minnesota Vikings at Highmark Stadium on November 13, 2022 in Orchard Park, New Yor
Damar Hamlin. Isaiah Vazquez/Getty Images
Read in app

It's possible that the hard tackle received by Damar Hamlin triggered a rare condition that led to his cardiac arrest, experts said in the wake of his startling collapse on Monday night.

Hamlin, 24, who plays for the Buffalo Bills, collapsed on the field during a game after tackling the Cincinnati Bengals player Tee Higgins.

Higgins collided hard with Hamlin's chest, striking with his right shoulder around where Hamlin's heart would be. After initially getting up, Hamlin collapsed and was rushed to the hospital.

Though it's too soon to know exactly what happened with Hamlin, medical experts laid out some possibilities based on what they saw.

They said this kind of strong impact to the chest could cause commotio cordis, a rare but life-threatening condition that can occur if the heart is struck in a very precise window of its beating.

Gregory Marcus, a cardiologist and professor of medicine at the University of California at San Francisco, described the condition to The Washington Post.

Buffalo Bills players surround a medical team tending to Damar Hamlin after his cardiac arrest on the football field.
Buffalo Bills players react to Hamlin's injury during a game against the Cincinnati Bengals on Monday.  Kirk Irwin/Getty Images

You must be extremely unlucky to get commotio cordis — Marcus said it happens when the chest is hit at a very specific moment of the heartbeat, in a 40-millisecond window.

Even a heavy impact like that from a football player (Higgins is 219 pounds and was running fast) is unlikely to directly damage the heart inside the rib cage. But it can cause an irregular surge of electricity, which can lead to sudden cardiac arrest even in those without preexisting heart issues.

Commotio cordis has mostly been reported among adolescents, but some cases have been reported among people over 20.

In an interview with the Boston TV station WCVB, Brien Barnewolt, an emergency-room doctor at Tufts Medical Center, also mentioned commotio cordis as a possibility.

Marcus and other experts cautioned that it's impossible to know what happened to Hamlin without seeing his medical records, which have not been released by the league or the hospital.

It's also possible that Hamlin had an underlying condition that had gone unnoticed.

The Sports Institute has suggested that undiagnosed underlying conditions are a main cause of sudden cardiac arrest in young athletes.

Chuck Hughes, the only player to die during an NFL game, collapsed in 1971 and was later found to have atherosclerosis, a clogged artery.

Marcus told The Post that a blow to the chest could also cause an aneurysm, exacerbating an undetected heart defect. Rajesh Dash, an associate professor in cardiovascular medicine at Stanford University, gave The Post a similar assessment.

The blow to Hamlin did not immediately seem dangerous. Ted Johnson, a former New England Patriots player, told WCVB that the play didn't seem to break any rules or be unusually violent.

After the tackle, Hamlin got up and adjusted his helmet. Then he collapsed and lay motionless, in cardiac arrest. Shocked teammates, some in tears, surrounded Hamlin as he received CPR. He was later rushed to the hospital.

The Bills said early Tuesday that Hamlin was in critical condition.

Barnewolt said Hamlin could recover if he got good care straight away. "I think the important thing is the quality of CPR and the timing of any kind of resuscitative efforts or defibrillation efforts that occur," he told WCVB.

"The sooner the better, obviously," he added. "People have been known to have great outcomes, even with prolonged cardiac arrest, if the resuscitative efforts are of high quality."

Correction: January 3, 2022 — An earlier version of this story misspelled Damar Hamlin's name as Hamil.

Read next

Doctor Marianne Guenot is a science reporter based in the UK who writes about health, AI, nuclear sciences, archeology, solar and planetary sciences, space exploration, and the commercial and political impact of science and tech. As part of her work, she visited the world's first final repository for nuclear waste, probed the economy of the climate crisis, untangled the complex factors playing into how the food chain pushes a health and climate crisis, tracked mysterious uranium cubes from the Manhattan project back to a Germany first prototype nuclear reactor, examined the motivations behind a tech tycoon's disastrous exploration of the deep sea, and deciphered the intricate business case behind NASA's return to the moon.Marianne holds a master's and Ph.D. in biomedicine and a master's degree in science communication. She worked with Business Insider from 2021 to 2024. Before then, she edited news and opinion at The Lancet and Nature Medicine. There, she wrote editorials read by leading policymakers. Selected works include.