Business Insider

Creditors urge Sears to shut down all its stores, calling its plan for survival 'wishful thinking'

Sears
Some of Sears' creditors want the company to shut down its remaining stores. AP Photo/Charlie Riedel
Read in app

Sears' creditors are demanding that the company shut down all its remaining stores.

The retailer's plan to survive bankruptcy is "nothing more than wishful thinking" and "an unjustified and foolhardy gamble with other people's money," a group of unsecured creditors has declared in a new filing. 

Sears has proposed cutting its store count to roughly 400 profitable stores, then selling the associated real estate to raise cash while the company works to return to profitability. The company had 687 stores when it filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in mid-October. 

Read more: Sears is closing another 40 stores — here's the complete list of locations

Creditors seem to believe that Sears has little chance of achieving profitability even with only its most successful stores, saying this is a "feat [Sears] could not accomplish in the six years leading up to the commencement of their" bankruptcy filing.

Unsecured creditors have the most to lose in bankruptcy cases. The debt they have extended to debtors — in this case, Sears — is not secured by any real estate or other assets. So they are the least protected in the event of a liquidation. 

The costs associated with continuing to keep Sears' stores open would drain some of the remaining funds owed to these creditors, they said.

Assuming Sears sells the remaining stores within three months, the company could burn through about $375 million, the filing reads. 

"By contrast, pursuing [going-out-of-business] sales for all of [Sears'] stores during the same time period may maximize the value of [Sears'] estates," it continues. 

A representative for Sears declined to comment. 

Read next

Hayley Peterson
Hayley Peterson
Hayley Peterson is an Executive Editor who oversees coverage of the economy, tech, media, advertising, defense, careers, and more.She was previously a chief correspondent at Business Insider and wrote breaking news, analysis, and in-depth investigations on large consumer companies, with an emphasis on retailers including Amazon, Walmart, major grocery chains, and department stores.Hayley won recognition from the Society for Advancing Business Editing and Writing in 2018 for "defining the retail apocalypse" through her reporting on retail job losses, the decline of Sears, and the impact of store closings on bondholders.Prior to joining Business Insider in 2013, Hayley was a White House correspondent and embedded on the presidential 2012 campaign trail.