Careers

Why you should never humblebrag in a job interview

Read in app
Couple Talking
Flickr / Nathan Colquhoun

So you've done your due diligence and prepared answers to the most common interview questions — including the dreaded, "What's your greatest weakness?"

Perhaps you've crafted an artful response that reframes your flaw as something positive: "I'm such a perfectionist that I drive myself crazy."

Unfortunately, this revelation is hardly what an interviewer wants to hear. New research suggests that "humblebragging" — a.k.a. boasting concealed by a complaint — is actually a turn-off.

In one experiment, researchers at Harvard Business School asked college students to write down how they'd answer a question about their biggest weakness in a job interview. Participants also wrote down why they would answer the question that way.

Afterward, research assistants reviewed all the responses and decided: how humblebrag-y they were, whether the participants were being honest, and how much they would want to hire the person who answered that way.

As it turns out, more than three-quarters of participants humblebragged. The most common humblebrags included being a perfectionist, working too hard, being too nice, and being too honest.

Moreover, the research assistants determined that the majority of people were being strategic about getting the hypothetical job (instead of honest) when they revealed their "weakness."

Perhaps most importantly, the research assistants indicated that they would be much less likely to hire the humblebraggers than those who seemed earnest. 

So how exactly did the honest people answer the question? Responses included: "I'm not always the best at staying organized," and "Sometimes I overreact to situations."

Of course, these findings don't imply that you should expound on the time you went berserk on a coworker because he turned in a project late. But a candidate who can show that she's self-aware and that she's working on improving her performance is probably the kind of person most interviewers want to hire.

Read next

Shana was a correspondent for Insider, where she covered career development and workplace culture.In 2022, she published "Don't Call It Quits" to help professionals who feel stuck in their careers find greater happiness at work.Shana spearheads the HR Insider series, for which she's interviewed talent chiefs at Microsoft and Goldman Sachs, shared tips from an ex-Googler on knowing when to change jobs, and demystified the hiring process at Salesforce. She regularly publishes news analysis; past topics have included burnout among US workers, gender and racial dynamics within HR, and the hybrid workplace.She has moderated programs at Chief and the Harvard Business School Club of New York and has appeared on Cheddar and Bold TV.Before beginning her career in journalism, Shana studied English and psychology at Brandeis University and received her master's degree in English literature from Columbia University.