Tech

REVIEW: There's only one real reason to buy the LG G5

Read in app
lg g5
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The G5 is LG's latest flagship premium smartphone, and it's very good.

It has a fresh design with new materials, as well as some interesting features that other phones don't have.

At the same time, it failed to impress in certain key areas.

You can buy the G5 now for about $650, but pricing will vary depending on your carrier.

Here's everything you need to know about the G5:

The LG G5 looks and feels more premium than previous "G" models, but it still doesn't compete with the other top smartphones out there.

htc 10, lg g5, galaxy s7
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The G5 is LG's first all-metal smartphone, save for the bottom front panel, which is made of plastic.

It's a welcome move away from the plastic smartphones that LG released in the last few years while other companies like Samsung, Apple, and HTC were releasing smartphones with premium materials, like metal and glass.

But the G5's metal build still doesn't quite match the premium feel of Samsung's Galaxy S7, the iPhone 6s, or HTC's new 10. 

It's the only premium smartphone that lets you replace the battery.

lg g5 removable battery
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

No other premium smartphone lets you swap out the battery.

LG will give you a free second battery and charging cradle that acts like an external battery if you buy the G5 before May 2.

Fast charging is a welcome feature.

lg g5 fast charging
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The G5 features the new USB-C standard for charging and connecting to computers. The new plug also lets it charge faster than the previous standard, microUSB.

That means you can give the G5 quick charging boosts throughout your day so you don't run out of battery.

With charging combined with the removable battery, there's no way you could possibly run out of juice on a typical day. The G5 is the longest lasting smartphone out of all its competitors. 

It works great as a premium Android smartphone.

lg g5 performance game
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The G5 runs on the latest and powerful Snapdragon 820 processor, which means fast performance. I can easily and quickly jump from app to app without much sign of slowing down. It also plays graphic-heavy games well. 

Hiding apps you don't like is annoying.

lg g5 app drawer
One of these G5s is missing a crucial Android feature. Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

I turned from balanced journalist to raging fan-boy when it seemed like LG ditched the Android app drawer on the G5.

The app drawer is where you can store your app icons so you can keep your home screen clean and uncluttered. It's arguably one of the main benefits of Android over iOS. 

Unfortunately, the app drawer isn't on the G5 by default. You can restore the app drawer, but it's a convoluted process that involves many, many steps

There is a workaround where you can store all your app icons into one folder and place it wherever you like, so it's not the end of the world. It's still not ideal, though. 

The removable bottom is a cool idea, but there isn't much you can do with it right now.

LG G5 battery camera module
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The G5's removable bottom gives the G5 a lot of potential to do cool things that its competitors can only dream of thanks to separate modules LG calls "Friends." 

For example, LG showed off a camera grip that gives you more control over taking pictures and video with the G5. However, a pre-release unit I tried didn't quite live up to expectations.

So far, the only Friend module available is the removable battery.

LG is letting developers design new modules for the G5. It'll be interesting to see what modules developers come up with, but for now, there isn't much. 

The fingerprint sensor on the back works pretty well, but it can be hard to use when you can't see it.

lg g5 fingerprint sensor
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

LG has finally given its premium smartphone a fingerprint sensor, but it's on the back where the home button is and it's fairly small, which sometimes makes it hard to find with your finger when you're trying to get into the G5 quickly.

Having a fingerprint sensor on the back isn't a bad thing. The Nexus 5X and 6P also have their fingerprint sensors on the back, and my colleague Ben Gilbert thinks it's great.

However, if you want to unlock your phone when it's sitting on your desk, you have to pick it up to reach the fingerprint sensor, unless you unlock it with your PIN on the screen. 

So, while the fingerprint sensor on the back is fine, a fingerprint sensor on the front like most phones is better.

No matter what, it'll come with the annoying apps (AKA bloatware) from your carrier because you can't buy it unlocked.

lg g5 bloatware 2
AT&T and other carriers keep adding their own apps that no one wants or uses, and it's a pain. Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

Unfortunately, you won't be able to buy the G5 unlocked directly from LG in the US. You have to buy it from your carrier, which means it'll come with a bunch of your carrier's awful apps that you can't uninstall.

It's not the worst thing in the world, as these apps don't take up too much of your storage, but it's still an annoyance. 

Speaking of storage...

You can add more storage with a microSD card.

lg g5 micro sd port
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

You can add to the G5's 32GB of built-in storage with a microSD card, which is great! Running out of space because of too many photos, videos, or music can be a thing of the past.

What's not great, however, is that you can't install apps on the microSD card, even though it's a feature in the current version of Android. That means LG actively disabled that feature on the G5. Samsung did the same thing for the Galaxy S7.

HTC's 10 is the only premium smartphone that lets you install apps onto a microSD card.

The dual camera should have been something else entirely.

LG G5
One mode on the G5 lets you awkwardly shoot with both cameras at once to form one picture. Screenshot

Tech Insider's photography and camera expert Rafi Letzter said the G5's dual camera is "just a weird, unnecessary gimmick."

The super wide-angle lens might look cool at first, giving your photos a fisheye GoPro-style effect, but you wouldn't want that effect for every photo. As a result, you wouldn't use the super-wide angle lens as often as, say, a lens that takes pictures with a narrower field-of-view that's good for portraits.

Using Rafi's words, "If LG had attached a second lens that was even twice as zoomed-in as its standard smartphone lens, that would have been much more useful."

That said, it does have a great zoom that looks better than any other smartphone camera I've tried.

iphone 6s plus galaxy s7 lg g5 zoom skitched
I've circled everything that looks better from the G5's zoom. It's basically the entire picture. Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The G5 can zoom in about as much as the other smartphone cameras in its class, but the pictures look much better.

They're clearer, sharper, and almost look like you took the picture without zooming in compared to the zoom on the Galaxy S7 and iPhone 6s Plus.

But the camera isn't as good as the Galaxy S7's.

LG G5 Galaxy S7 comparison aspect ratio
Rafi Letzter/Tech Insider

Despite having more megapixels than the Galaxy S7's 12-megapixel camera, the G5's main 16-megapixel shooter isn't quite as good. 

The S7 is sharper, does better in low light, has better autofocus, and deals better with colors compared to the G5.

Check out Rafi Letzter's comparison of the LG G5's camera with the Galaxy S7's.

The G5 is a good Android phone with some neat features, but it's not a home run.

LG G5 front colors
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The G5 is a good, solid Android phone, and it's your only option if you want a removable battery.

But if that doesn't matter to you, the Galaxy S7 is the better choice for its camera, gorgeous design, and nifty features like wireless charging and water-resistance, all for a similar $650 price tag.

Read next

Antonio Villas-Boas was a consumer tech expert with over a decade of experience testing and reviewing smartphones, tablets, computers, smartwatches, and phone carriers.ExperienceAntonio joined the Business Insider team in 2015 as a tech reporter on the news desk and moved to the service journalism team in 2020. During his time as Business Insider’s senior tech reporter, Antonio developed industry-leading battery-life tests for smartphones and tablets, and covered and reviewed hundreds (if not thousands) of products from major brands like Apple, Google, Samsung, and OnePlus since as far back as Samsung’s Galaxy S6, the original Apple Watch, and the very first Google Pixel. This decade-plus of experience has given him tremendous insights into what consumer tech truly stands the test of time and what will be irrelevant in just a few years' time (RIP The Pebble).Antonio is also an experienced deal hunter, surfacing the best discounts on phones, laptops, and smartwatches for readers during sale events like Prime Day, Black Friday, and Cyber Monday. Previously, Antonio was a consumer-electronics analyst at PCMag and ran his own blog. Why you can trust AntonioAntonio approaches all his reviews not only as a tech expert but as a consumer himself. He reads every word of fine print in the phone carrier plans he reviews, and is deeply skeptical of deals that promise you the latest iPhone model for free. (Spoiler: it might be “free,” but you could be stuck with it for three years.)He largely recommends less expensive and small-scale fixes to upgrade your existing tech before considering buying the latest and flashiest in new tech. Antonio believes his role as the go-to “tech guy” for his family and friends extends to his readers as well; he only recommends products that have stood up to the testing process.Scripps News, NewsNation, Fox 5 DC, NBC LX, and Rich DeMuro’s “Rich On Tech” radio show have requested his commentary and expertise. ExpertiseHis expertise includes:
  • Phones, including the iPhone, Google Pixel, and Samsung Galaxy models
  • Phone accessories, including charging cables, phone cases, and protection plans
  • Smartwatches, including the Apple Watch, Galaxy Watch, Pixel Watch
  • Mobile carrier plans, including major carriers and MVNOs
  • Tablets, including iPads and Galaxy Tabs
  • Laptops and computers, including MacBooks and Windows models
  • Computer accessories, including mice, keyboards, and monitors
EducationAntonio graduated from Colgate University in 2009 with a bachelor's degree in history.Outside of workBesides testing tech products, Antonio is also a full time dad to two young kids. His ideal day would be spent on a lake in the Adirondacks.Learn more about how our team of experts tests and reviews products at Insider here.Learn more about how we test tech and electronics.