Food

I made Ina Garten's 'outrageous brownies,' the most popular dessert at her famous store. They tasted incredible.

Brownies on a glass dish.
I made Ina Garten's outrageous brownies, and the delicious dessert lived up to the hype. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider
Read in app

As a longtime "Barefoot Contessa" fan, I've been making my way through Ina Garten's desserts to improve my baking skills.

Her mocha-chocolate icebox cake remains one of my favorite homemade desserts, and my family still talks about her iconic Beatty's Chocolate Cake.

So, naturally, next on the list had to be her outrageous brownies.

Garten's outrageous brownies were the most popular dish at her Barefoot Contessa store, which launched her cooking career.

Barefoot Contessa store
The Barefoot Contessa store in East Hampton, New York, is seen here in 2002. Matthew Peyton/Getty Images

Garten left a job at the White House to run Barefoot Contessa, working 18-hour days to turn it into a success in the Hamptons. She ran the store for nearly two decades, and her first cookbook, "The Barefoot Contessa Cookbook," featured its most popular recipes.

In the introduction to the dessert section, Garten writes that her husband Jeffrey's affection for her was "initially linked to the boxes of homemade brownies I used to send him in college."

And when Garten started running Barefoot Contessa, it was her brownies that were flying off the shelves — so much that she sold "like a thousand" a week, she said.

Garten's outrageous brownies feature an outrageously awesome amount of chocolate.

Ingredients for Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
Ingredients for Ina Garten's outrageous brownies. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

To make a serving of 20 (large) brownies, you'll need:

  • 1 pound of unsalted butter
  • 1 pound, plus 12 ounces, of semisweet chocolate chips
  • 6 ounces of bitter chocolate
  • 6 extra-large eggs
  • 3 cups of chopped walnuts
  • 2 ¼ cups of sugar
  • 1 ¼ cups of all-purpose flour
  • 3 tablespoons of instant coffee granules
  • 2 tablespoons of pure vanilla extract
  • 1 tablespoon of baking powder
  • 1 teaspoon of salt

I preheated the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, then buttered and floured my baking sheet.

Greasing pan for Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
I buttered my baking pan, then sprinkled flour on top. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

Garten recommends using a 12-inch by 18-inch by 1-inch baking sheet for this recipe.

Next, I began melting my butter and chocolate.

Melting butter for Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
I melted my butter and chocolate over a pot of simmering water. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

I sliced my butter into knobs, melting them with the bitter chocolate and one pound of the chocolate chips in a saucepan over simmering water.

Once everything had melted, I allowed the mixture to slightly cool.

Melting chocolate for Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
My melted chocolate. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

My kitchen already smelled delicious.

While I waited, I got the wet ingredients ready.

Mixing batter for Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
I stirred the eggs together with vanilla, instant coffee, and sugar. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

I added my eggs to a large bowl, along with the vanilla, instant coffee granules, and sugar. Garten loves using instant coffee in her desserts to enhance the chocolate flavor.

I then carefully stirred the ingredients together, making sure not to beat the eggs.

Then, I added the warm chocolate mixture.

The batter for Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
I added the chocolate mixture to my egg mixture. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

I stirred the chocolate mixture into the egg mixture and allowed it to cool to room temperature.

Garten said it's very important to allow the batter to cool before adding the chocolate chips because if the chips melt, they will ruin the brownies.

While my chocolate mixture cooled, I prepped the dry ingredients.

Sifting flour for Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
I sifted the flour, baking powder, and salt. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

I sifted one cup of flour, as well as the baking powder and salt, in a separate bowl before adding them to the cooled chocolate mixture.

"This recipe doesn't have a lot of flour, which is why they're so fudgy," Garten explained while demonstrating the brownies on an episode of "Barefoot Contessa."

I tossed the walnuts and 12 ounces of chocolate chips with ¼ cup of flour.

Chocolate chips for Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
Flouring the chocolate chips and walnuts keeps them from sinking to the bottom. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

Garten notes in her recipe that flouring the chocolate chips and walnuts keeps them from sinking to the bottom of the brownies while they're baking.

I added chocolate chips and walnuts to the mixture, then poured my batter onto the baking sheet.

Making batter for Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
My batter with the chocolate chips and walnuts. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

It was time to bake!

After baking the brownies for 20 minutes, I hit the baking sheet against the oven rack.

Pre-baked Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
My baking sheet before going into the oven. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

Garten explained on "Barefoot Contessa" that this was a crucial step during baking because air builds up between the brownies and the pan.

"I just pick up the pan and rap it on the baking rack and it releases all that air," she said.

I baked my brownies for another 15 minutes, until a toothpick came out clean from the center.

Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
It took 35 minutes to bake the brownies. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

Garten said it's important not to overbake the brownies.

As I cut my brownies into squares, I could see how fluffy and thick each one was.

Ina Garten's Outrageous Brownies
My brownies looked absolutely delicious. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

My brownies looked super luscious and fudgy, each packed with chocolate chips and walnuts. I couldn't wait to dig in!

Garten's outrageous brownies were outrageously delicious — and lived up to the hype.

Brownies on a glass dish.
I can't wait to make Garten's outrageous brownies again. Anneta Konstantinides/Business Insider

When I saw "outrageous" in the name, I should've known Garten's brownies would taste incredible. After all, I still rave about her outrageous garlic bread to this day, and I made it for the first time four years ago.

Garten's brownies are just so decadent and delicious. The chocolate is rich and satisfying, and the crunch of the chips and walnuts makes for a great texture contrast. And while they're super easy to make, Garten's outrageous brownies are packed with so much flavor that they still taste elevated.

In the introduction to the dessert section of her first cookbook, Garten writes that "a homemade dessert is a special reward." Well, her outrageous brownies might be one of the best rewards of all.

Read next

IMG_1749.JPG
Anneta Konstantinides
Anneta Konstantinides is a lifestyle correspondent at Business Insider, with a focus on food and travel. She loves taking readers inside Michelin-starred kitchens and exploring the world of fine-dining, and she's always trying to find the best Ina Garten and Gordon Ramsay recipes. Her second home is LAX, where she's often catching a flight and reviewing airlines.Anneta has also been reporting on the pageant industry for the last six years and has interviewed every Miss USA and Miss Universe winner since 2019. She was a finalist at the LA Press Club Awards for her investigation into the  2022 Miss USA scandal and was featured in The New York Times Presents episode "How to Fix a Pageant" on Hulu in September 2023. After graduating from UCLA with a B.A in English Literature and a minor in film & television, Anneta worked as a journalist in London, Sydney, New York City, Los Angeles, and Washington, DC. You can reach Anneta at akonstantinides@jkmperu.com.