Tech

The cameras in Google's new smartphones are seriously impressive

Read in app
nexus 6p vs iphone 6s plus
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

Both of Google's new phones, the Nexus 5X and Nexus 6P, have the same 12.3 megapixel camera, and today, they compete against the iPhone 6s Plus' upgraded 12-megapixel shooter.

The Nexus camera has a few tricks, like super-fast laser auto-focusing and huge 1.55 micron sensors that should allow the Nexus to dominate in poorly lit situations. But the iPhone 6s Plus has optical image stabilization (OIS), which takes care of any vibrations that could blur a shot.

This is a straight up Google versus Apple fight, so check out the following pictures and see which has the best camera.

To the casual user who wants to "shoot n' show," the Nexus shoots a better, more dramatic photo with deeper, if saturated, colors. But to anyone who wants to apply filters on apps like Instagram or edit their photos, the iPhone is better as it's more accurate and well exposed.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp grass
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The Nexus can saturate bright, vibrant colors a little too much, which robs subjects of detail. For example, it's harder to see individual petals in the Nexus shot. The iPhone shot looks washed out, like it has a mist in front of the camera, but you can see more detail.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp flowers
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The Nexus can over expose, as seen in the featureless clouds above the building. The iPhone captures more cloud detail while maintaining good lighting throughout the picture.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp building 2
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

Over-exposure in bright outdoor environments is a problem on the Nexus, as you can barely see any of the building's detail on the sunlit surface. So far, the iPhone performs better in bright, outdoor environments.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp building
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The edges of the building look much sharper in the Nexus shot. The iPhone seems to soften them a bit.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp building closeup
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

In this mixed shade/sunlight situation, I'd be glad to have the iPhone. Colors are deeper on the Nexus shot, but the sky through the trees in the middle is again overexposed. The sky through the trees is clearly blue in the iPhone shot.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp building in woods
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

Same thing here with the sky's blue color piercing through the leaves. There's more over-exposure in the Nexus photo while you can clearly see blue sky in the iPhone photo.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp yellow leaves
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

But the iPhone isn't immune to over-exposure, either. Just check out the leaves on the very left hand side on each photo. The overexposure in the iPhone shot washed away their detail. I'd rather have the Nexus for darker subjects, even in bright outdoor situations.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp pond
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The iPhone triumphs in flat outdoor light, as there's better contrast between the darker and brighter parts of this burnt log.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp wood
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The Nexus gains the upper hand indoors. It captures the flower's deeper colors while capturing all the detail.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp flower closeup
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The iPhone colors look paler and almost washed out compared to the Nexus, and there's more purple fringing around the leaves in the bright spot on the top right.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp indoor plants
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

And while the iPhone captures a better blue on Frida Kahlo's pyramid, the yellows and reds are washed out. I'd rather show my friends the Nexus picture in this case.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp pyramid
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

And there's no contest in dark environments. Nexus wins flat out, as the iPhone photo is grainy while the Nexus' photo is not.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp dark fruit
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The Nexus photo's colors are richer here.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp indoor gourd
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

And the Nexus captures much sharper detail.

iphone 6s vs nexus 6p
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The Nexus is far sharper, which is especially noticeable in the details of the wet and mossy rocks. The Nexus also handled the running water better in this shot.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp water
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The iPhone seems to process this naturally lit indoor shot more than the Nexus does, as it's compensating for the lack of light. You can't see as much detail in the iPhone shot, but the lighting is much better.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp skin natural light
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The Nexus' new laser auto-focus did a poor job here. But it deals well with artificial lighting and makes for a more even skin tones across my face. The iPhone captures brighter patches.

New nexus vs iphone camera comp skin tone indoor
Antonio Villas-Boas/Tech Insider

The final word.

It's a tough call because the iPhone did best outdoors and the Nexus was generally better for indoor situations. But the iPhone is still has the best camera in a smartphone you can get because you can compensate for its deficiencies with filters or editing.

The Nexus generally takes pictures with that compensation already added, which makes it difficult if you didn't want that compensation in the first place. It's better and easier to have a picture you can add to rather than take away from. Still, for $450, the Nexus has a pretty stunning camera.

The Nexus put up an excellent fight, and it's the best camera on an Android smartphone I've seen so far.

Read next

Antonio Villas-Boas was a consumer tech expert with over a decade of experience testing and reviewing smartphones, tablets, computers, smartwatches, and phone carriers.ExperienceAntonio joined the Business Insider team in 2015 as a tech reporter on the news desk and moved to the service journalism team in 2020. During his time as Business Insider’s senior tech reporter, Antonio developed industry-leading battery-life tests for smartphones and tablets, and covered and reviewed hundreds (if not thousands) of products from major brands like Apple, Google, Samsung, and OnePlus since as far back as Samsung’s Galaxy S6, the original Apple Watch, and the very first Google Pixel. This decade-plus of experience has given him tremendous insights into what consumer tech truly stands the test of time and what will be irrelevant in just a few years' time (RIP The Pebble).Antonio is also an experienced deal hunter, surfacing the best discounts on phones, laptops, and smartwatches for readers during sale events like Prime Day, Black Friday, and Cyber Monday. Previously, Antonio was a consumer-electronics analyst at PCMag and ran his own blog. Why you can trust AntonioAntonio approaches all his reviews not only as a tech expert but as a consumer himself. He reads every word of fine print in the phone carrier plans he reviews, and is deeply skeptical of deals that promise you the latest iPhone model for free. (Spoiler: it might be “free,” but you could be stuck with it for three years.)He largely recommends less expensive and small-scale fixes to upgrade your existing tech before considering buying the latest and flashiest in new tech. Antonio believes his role as the go-to “tech guy” for his family and friends extends to his readers as well; he only recommends products that have stood up to the testing process.Scripps News, NewsNation, Fox 5 DC, NBC LX, and Rich DeMuro’s “Rich On Tech” radio show have requested his commentary and expertise. ExpertiseHis expertise includes:
  • Phones, including the iPhone, Google Pixel, and Samsung Galaxy models
  • Phone accessories, including charging cables, phone cases, and protection plans
  • Smartwatches, including the Apple Watch, Galaxy Watch, Pixel Watch
  • Mobile carrier plans, including major carriers and MVNOs
  • Tablets, including iPads and Galaxy Tabs
  • Laptops and computers, including MacBooks and Windows models
  • Computer accessories, including mice, keyboards, and monitors
EducationAntonio graduated from Colgate University in 2009 with a bachelor's degree in history.Outside of workBesides testing tech products, Antonio is also a full time dad to two young kids. His ideal day would be spent on a lake in the Adirondacks.Learn more about how our team of experts tests and reviews products at Insider here.Learn more about how we test tech and electronics.