Tech

Elon Musk thinks some of ChatGPT's responses are 'concerning'

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman and Elon Musk
Sam Altman, the CEO of OpenAI, and Elon Musk. Getty
Read in app

ChatGPT has gotten under the skin of many commentators in recent weeks.

Among them, apparently, is Elon Musk, the CEO of Twitter and one of the founders of OpenAI, which created ChatGPT. The billionaire has recently criticized several of the chatbot's answers.

On Monday, in response to a retweet of a screenshot of a ChatGPT's answer to a question about a hypothetical scenario involving racial slurs, Musk said, "Concerning."

The question was posed by Aaron Sibarium, a journalist at the conservative publication The Washington Free Beacon. "ChatGPT says it is never morally permissible to utter a racial slur—even if doing so is the only way to save millions of people from a nuclear bomb," Sibarium tweeted with the screenshot.

In December, in response to a tweet from Alex Epstein, an energy expert who has advocated the use of fossil fuels, with what appeared to be a screenshot of a ChatGPT answer refusing to argue in favor of fossil fuels, Musk said, "There is great danger in training an AI to lie."

"The use of fossil fuels has significant negative impacts on the environment and contributes to climate change," the chatbot appeared to say in response to Epstein's request. It was unclear which part of the response Musk was referring to. When Insider gave the chatbot the same prompt, it provided an argument advocating the use of fossil fuels but would not provide an article saying the use of fossil fuels has helped the environment.

Musk also left two fire emojis under a tweet from Delian Asparouhov, a principal at Founders Fund, expressing disbelief at what appeared to be ChatGPT's contrasting answers to requests concerning President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump.

Musk has at times seemed complimentary about OpenAI's tech. In early December, he said the chatbot was "scary good," and he has more neutrally highlighted the bot's various abilities.

Researchers said in December that ChatGPT appeared to be capable of passing the US medical-licensing exam, though the research was still being peer-reviewed. Several schools and universities have banned the chatbot over fears it could help students cheat on their homework.

Others are concerned that the bot's ethical standards are not high enough. Several cases of bias have emerged, and Sam Altman, OpenAI's CEO, acknowledged last week that ChatGPT had "shortcomings around bias."

OpenAI says it's been improving the technology since it was released in November, partly because of feedback from users.

"If you tried ChatGPT when it just came out versus today, you will see a significant difference in terms of how much misinformation and how much biased content it puts out," Abhishek Gupta, the founder of the Montreal AI Ethics Institute, told Insider.

Representatives for OpenAI and Musk did not immediately respond to Insider's request for comment made outside normal working hours.

Read next

Beatrice Nolan was a tech reporter on the business news team in the UK. She joined Insider in January 2022 as a fellow on Business Insider's careers desk. Beatrice covered tech and the future of work, with a focus on artificial intelligence. Some of her stories and early experiments with ChatGPT are widely cited. Beatrice has also discussed her work covering AI trends on panels and radio shows, including NPR.She was based in Business Insider's London office and graduated from the University of  York with a bachelor's degree in English.Featured Articles:Artists say AI image generators are copying their style to make thousands of new images — and it's completely out of their control.ChatGPT was a black swan eventFinland is the world's happiest country, but Finns say we're confusing happiness for something elseThe world is splitting between those who use ChatGPT to get better, smarter, richer — and everyone elseThis man used AI to write and illustrate a children's book in one weekend. He wasn't prepared for the backlash.ChatGPT has only been around for 2 months and is causing untold chaosTwo professors who say they caught students cheating on essays with ChatGPT explain why AI plagiarism can be hard to proveChatGPT wrote college application essays. Admissions professionals said they passed for essays written by students but wouldn't have a chance at any top colleges.College professors are considering creative ways to stop students from using AI to cheatChatGPT wrote my cover letters. Here's how recruiters responded.