Healthcare

Leaked email: Mental-health startup Cerebral will stop prescribing most controlled drugs like Xanax and Adderall

Kyle Robertson and Ho Anh
Cerebral's founders, Ho Anh and Kyle Robertson. Cerebral
Read in app

The $4.8 billion mental-health startup Cerebral just announced a major change to its business, as it faces mounting scrutiny from federal investigators over how it prescribes controlled substances.

In an email to staff Monday evening, Cerebral CEO Kyle Robertson said the company's clinicians will stop prescribing most controlled substances to new patients starting May 20 and to existing patients starting October 15. Controlled substances like the benzodiazepine Xanax and the stimulant Adderall are classified as such because of the risks involved with prescribing, such as the potential for addiction.

"We want to assure you that we are confident in the future of the business. While we will no longer provide care using controlled medications, we will continue to provide a holistic approach to care with both behavioral and medication-based treatments (when clinically appropriate)," Robertson wrote in the email seen by Insider.

Cerebral confirmed the decision to Insider in a statement.

"We can confirm tonight that the company's leadership team has made a unanimous decision supported by its board of directors to move forward with a decision to no longer offer mental health services involving the prescription of controlled substances," Cerebral said on Monday. "This decision was spearheaded by our clinical and regulatory teams, and we will be releasing more details about how we will do this safely and in the best interests of our patients and clinicians later this week." 

Cerebral, backed by venture-capital firms, including SoftBank and Oak HC/FT, provides medication and therapy online to people with anxiety, depression, ADHD, and other conditions. 

The move to discontinue controlled substances comes after months of increasing scrutiny from the federal government, newsrooms, and pharmacies over its prescribing practices. 

Prior to the coronavirus pandemic, federal law prohibited clinicians from prescribing such highly regulated drugs to patients without an in-person appointment. Only a handful of companies took advantage of relaxed rules for prescribing controlled substances online amid the public health crisis.  

In the email, Robertson said Cerebral began prescribing controlled substances in 2020 at the height of the pandemic when people lacked access to the in-person care required to receive those medications. It's making the change now because of the ability for patients to return to an in-person or hybrid care model, he said.

Cerebral previously said it would halt prescribing controlled substances like the stimulant Adderall for new patients with ADHD starting in May, The Wall Street Journal reported. National pharmacy chains had expressed concerns that clinicians at Cerebral and another company are writing too many prescriptions for stimulants, per The Journal.

Federal agencies have also taken notice of Cerebral. The US Drug Enforcement Administration and the US Department of Justice are investigating the startup, as Insider exclusively reported in May. 

Cerebral will continue writing prescriptions for Suboxone

Robertson said patients with existing prescriptions for controlled substances to treat conditions like ADHD and anxiety will be notified of the upcoming changes and encouraged to visit with their Cerebral clinician to develop a plan to taper off their current medication and begin another treatment option, or transition away from Cerebral's care.

Cerebral will continue to prescribe controlled substances to patients with opioid use disorder, however, because of the lack of access to such care, Robertson said. The company launched a program to treat opioid use disorder with Narcan and the controlled substance Suboxone in March

Cerebral is making other changes to its clinical policies and marketing strategies to ensure quality of care and patient safety, Robertson said in the email. 

Further, Robertson said Cerebral is recruiting more psychiatrists and psychiatric nurse practitioners, and it's reviewing how it pays its clinicians "to ensure that all incentives align with a value-based care model," the email said. Cerebral has relied largely on nurse practitioners to prescribe medication to patients.

Do you have a tip about Cerebral that you want to share? Contact Blake Dodge (+1 252-241-3117) and Shelby Livingston (+1 843-412-6857) using the encrypted app Signal.

Read next

Blake Dodge was formerly a correspondent at Business Insider, where she wrote about tech and healthcare. Her coverage focused on tech entrepreneurs trying to break into the healthcare industry, sometimes harming patients in the process. But Blake also wrote about their profound ambitions with nuance and, occasionally, optimism. Her scoops and exclusive stories were cited by The Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg, STAT News, Axios, and more.Prior to BI, Blake wrote about healthcare and politics at Newsweek, Bloomberg, and the Center for Public Integrity. She graduated from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill as a Morehead-Cain scholar, where she competed in the 800-meter on the varsity track team, placing 6th in the ACC at 2:07.02. Selected stories:2,000 leaked documents and employees say Silicon Valley healthcare startup Cerebral harmed hundreds of patients and prescribed serious medication with abandonA little-known startup is automating IVF with robots and AI. It could change infertility forever.Buzzy startups failed to fix mental-health care. Now their mistakes are fueling the space's next generation.Inside Cityblock's meteoric rise: How a Google spinoff built a $1 billion business and convinced Silicon Valley to bet on healthcare for the sickest patientsTeladoc acquired Livongo to recreate healthcare. A rushed union, a wave of senior exits, and sky-high expectations are testing the $14 billion bet.Exclusive: Grand Rounds, now Included Health, is gearing up for an IPO in early 2022Amazon wants to provide medical care to workers at major companies. Here's an inside look at Amazon Care.Oracle cofounder Larry Ellison says he wants to transform healthcare. First his company will have to tackle a billion-dollar mess.Apple dreamed of making healthcare easy. Then it silenced its medical experts.
Shelby Livingston was a healthcare correspondent at Business Insider, reporting on how healthcare is paid for and delivered in the US.She covered health insurers and healthcare providers, as well as digital-health startups seeking to transform the industry.Shelby previously covered the health-insurance industry at Modern Healthcare. She won a 2018 Jesse H. Neal Award for her reporting on access to treatment for opioid addiction. She was a finalist for the 2021 NIHCM Awards for her reporting on the evolving roles of community pharmacists.She received her master's degree in journalism from Northwestern University's Medill School of Journalism after graduating from Clemson University. She lives in Nashville, Tennessee.Selected stories