Lifestyle

The 9 hottest restaurant reservations to snag in New York City right now

misi williamsburg
Misi, an always packed spot in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is one of six Italian restaurants on this list. Misi
Read in app

New York City has a legendary dining scene and reservations at its hottest restaurants are unsurprisingly hard to land.

Resy, an American Express-owned restaurant reservation booking platform, has a feature that allows users to set notifications that will alert them whenever a reservation becomes available at a completely booked restaurant. The feature makes it just a little easier to have the best burger or veal parmesan in the city sooner.

It also indicates which reservations are the most coveted — a Resy representative provided Business Insider with a list of which constantly booked restaurants have had the most notification alerts set so far this year. 

Keep reading below for a look at the most in-demand NYC restaurant reservations below, listed in ascending order by number of alerts set since January 1, 2020.

9. The Polo Bar

The Polo Bar NYC
Ralph Lauren

8. Misi

misi williamsburg
Misi

Misi, renowned chef Missy Robbins' restaurant, serves $30 "out-of-this-world pasta" in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.

The Italian spot opened in 2018 with varied critical reception but walk-in wait times are known to exceed 90 minutes.

7. Llama San

Llama San
Llama San/Instagram

Chef Erik Ramirez' West Village Peruvian-Japanese fusion restaurant opened this past fall. As of now, the next available reservation for a party of two is at 10 p.m. on a Sunday at the beginning of March.

Main dishes ranging from clams, fish, duck sausage, and beef heart cost around $25.

6. Don Angie

Don Angie NYC
Don Angie/Instagram

Don Angie is an Italian restaurant helmed by a husband-and-wife chef team in the West Village.

The restaurant opened in 2017 and is known for its cantaloupe caramelle ($22) and its decadent lasagna for two ($64).

5. Rezdôra

Rezdora NYC
Rezdôra

Located in the Flatiron district, the recently opened Rezdôra serves house-made pasta and other Italian fare. 

Rezdôra's pasta dishes all cost under $25 — its regional pasta tasting costs $90.

4. I Sodi

I Sodi NYC
I Sodi

I Sodi is a tiny restaurant in West Village and a love letter to chef Rita Sodi's Tuscan roots.

The pastas are under $30 and dinner mains like rabbit, pork chops, and branzino hover around $40.

3. 4 Charles Prime Rib

4 Charles Prime Rib
4 Charles Prime Rib

4 Charles Prime Rib is a West Village steakhouse supper club that's known for its burger.

The burger, dressed with an egg and bacon, costs $36. Its steak offerings range in price from $50 to $100.

2. Lilia

Lilia NYC
Lilia

Lilia is the second Miss Robbins restaurant on this list, in addition to Misi. Both are located in Williamsburg, Brooklyn — but Lilia is housed in what was once an auto body shop.

Pastas at Lilia cost around $20 while other popular fish dishes are closer to $30.

1. Carbone

carbone
Carbone/Facebook

Carbone, the most popular restaurant in NYC so far this year, is another classic Italian spot in Greenwich Village with old school charm. It's been a mainstay on NYC dining lists since it opened in 2013.

The menu is expansive, but a fan-favorite dish, the veal parmesan, costs $55.

Read next

Taylor reports on real estate, wealth, and travel. She covers the housing market and where people are moving, from up-and-coming cities to noted luxurious enclaves. She joined Business Insider in 2019. Since then, she has investigated how the richest ZIP code in the US obtained coronavirus antibody tests for residents before they were readily available, interviewed Michelin-starred chefs, and analyzed how the pandemic rendered the American dream of homeownership practically unattainable. Taylor is from Miami, Florida, and holds a master's in journalism from Northwestern University. Let her know where you're trying to buy a house or secure a second passport at tborden@jkmperu.com. Follow her on Twitter @taylormborden.