Travel

I stayed at 2 all-inclusive resorts in Central America. I'm still dreaming about one of them a year later.

The author in a pool at an all-inclusive resort in Panama.
I visited all-inclusive resorts in Belize and Panama. Monica Humphries/Business Insider
Read in app

For years, I avoided all-inclusive resorts.

I assumed the term was synonymous with crowded beaches, buffet lines, and over-chlorinated pools.

But last year, I accidentally booked an all-inclusive stay in Belize. Two months later, I traveled to Panama and, once again, stayed at an all-inclusive property.

Not only did these stays change my view of the vacation style, but they also turned out to be some of the best places I've ever visited. A year later, I'm still daydreaming about the Panama resort.

Last February, I had my eyes set on sleeping in an overwater bungalow. The place I chose also happened to be all-inclusive.

The exterior of the premier overwater bungalow.
The exterior of the premier overwater bungalow. Monica Humphries/Business Insider

When I think of a dream tropical vacation, an image of an overwater bungalow is bound to cross my mind.

Sleeping above the ocean, swimming in crystal-clear waters, and vacationing next to marine life is the epitome of a tropical vacation.

To curate that vision, I assumed it would involve a flight to Tahiti, where overwater bungalows originated, or a trek to the Maldives.

Then, I learned there were bungalows in Belize. Thatch Caye, a Muy'Ono Resort, sits on a small private island off the coast of Dangriga, Belize.

The property has eight overwater bungalows. When I visited, the rate was around $950 a night for two guests and included meals, non-alcoholic and alcoholic beverages, boat transfers, and aquatic gear like paddleboards and kayaks. Business Insider received a media rate for the stay.

The experience at Thatch Caye was magical.

The volleyball court at Thatch Caye.
The volleyball court at Thatch Caye. Monica Humphries/Business Insider

I stayed in a premier overwater bungalow, which meant that my friend and I enjoyed evenings watching the sunset from our bungalow's hammock and nights falling asleep to the wind whistling through the palm-frond roof.

Plus, staying on a private island — with room for only 30 guests — created a more intimate experience than what I envisioned at massive all-inclusives.

Instead of bumping into strangers at the pool or fighting over loungers at the beach, I got to know other guests visiting the property.

Thatch Caye also had the traditional perks of an all-inclusive. There was endless access to tropical drinks, and, yes, there was a buffet. However, instead of all-day access to food, there were set times when meals were served each day.

I spent two blissful nights at the resort. My friend and I paddleboarded around the island, adventured on a scuba diving excursion (with additional costs), and sipped cocktails hanging above the ocean.

It was an all-inclusive experience that completely demolished all my perceptions of the vacation style.

I loved it so much that I booked another all-inclusive stay two months later.

Isla Palenque is a five-star private island resort off the coast of Panama.
The reporter's casita at Isla Palenque. Monica Humphries/Business Insider

With the words "all-inclusive" no longer deterring me from a resort, I headed to Isla Palenque two months after visiting Belize to end a weeklong trip to Panama.

The resort, which sits on a little island on Panama's coast in the Gulf of Chiriqui, is home to eight beachfront casitas,

Guests can access seven private beaches, a shared pool, a lounge area, a restaurant, and a bar.

The resort is similarly priced. During my stay, the cost was about $980 a day for two guests. That included boat transfers, meals, non-alcoholic beverages, and daily experiences. Business Insider received a media rate for the stay.

After Thatch Caye, I wasn't sure if my expectations for an all-inclusive were fair.

Isla Palenque is a five-star private island resort off the coast of Panama.
The pool and lounge on Isla Palenque. Monica Humphries/Business Insider

Thatch Caye was a blast. As someone who has hotel- and resort-hopped all over the world, I thought the experience far exceeded its 3-star rating.

Isla Palenque, on the other hand, is a five-star resort. I was curious if I'd notice much of a difference between the two luxury all-inclusive stays.

The island exceeded the high standards Thatch Caye set.

Isla Palenque is a five-star private island resort off the coast of Panama.
A sunset on Isla Palenque. Monica Humphries/Business Insider

A few things made this all-inclusive experience even more luxurious.

While Thatch Caye felt intimate, Isla Palenque felt even more private. I sipped morning coffee on beaches by myself and got lost paddleboarding around the shores.

The island also hosted complimentary activities each day. I spent one evening at a yoga class and another snorkeling and picnicking on a private beach.

The food was more elevated, with multi-course lunches and dinners from a rotating menu. There was also an all-day menu, so when hunger crept up one afternoon between lunch and dinner, I ordered a bowl of fresh ceviche to tide me over — an all-inclusive perk I appreciated.

The staff was welcoming, and my accommodations were more upscale, with more space, privacy, and an enormous outdoor bathroom.

It's been one year since I visited Isla Palenque, and I haven't stopped thinking about the island.

Isla Palenque is a five-star private island resort off the coast of Panama.
The dock at Isla Palenque. Monica Humphries/Business Insider

Pristine beaches, overgrown jungles, full itineraries, and a welcoming staff earned Isla Palenque a spot as one of my favorite resorts — it being all-inclusive was an added bonus to the stay.

There are plenty of all-inclusives left to explore across Central America, but when I return to Panama, I'll be making a stop back at Isla Palenque.

Read next

Monica was a travel reporter and photographer based in Colorado. She covered a range of topics with a focus on alternative living and luxury travel. When she's not in the mountains, you could find her documenting what it's like to trek gorillas in Uganda, reporting on the latest short-term rental scam, and photographing private islands in Central America.Before working at Business Insider, Monica specialized in solutions journalism at the startup NationSwell. She graduated from the University of Florida in 2018 with a degree in journalism. You can reach her at humphriesmonica@gmail.com and follow her on Instagram.Popular ArticlesMy week in Mexico's hidden paradiseBoquete, Panama, was once a quiet town home to rainforests and coffee farms. Then came the retirees.Strangers kept arriving at an LA man's home, thinking it was their Airbnb. The company left him hanging for more than a year.Van-life couples share what the lifestyle is really like and how it can make or break a relationshipI thought I'd hate all-inclusive resorts. Then I went to one.Americans are flocking to Hawaii, but locals don't want tourists visiting now — and some wish they'd stop altogetherI had the most luxurious stay of my life in Panama. Now, I want every tropical vacation to include a private island.